Almond Sugar Cookies!  YUM!

At Short North Piece of Cake we strive to always have a selection of our cut out cookies available.  Each season or holiday we make your favorite cookie desgns, but special orders are always welcome.  Special orders require 3 days notice and a minimum quantity of 24.

PHONE or FAX your Lunch Orders: Phone: 614.421.0399 | Fax: 614.737.0401

VISA & MasterCard accepted 
(not currently taking orders via email)

Download Our Print-Friendly  LUNCH MENU

• Soup of the Day $4.50/Bowl $3.00/Cup

Made fresh daily using the finest ingredients. 
Served with Veggies or Roll. Soup and half sandwich $6.25
 

• Panini $6.75 full / $4.25 half
All panini served on ciabatta bread or flatbread wrap

        The Italian

• Chef's Salad $7.00
Romaine lettuce topped with grilled chicken, boiled egg, carrots, cheddar cheese, and bacon.
Served with fresh bread and your choice of dressing.

• Club Croissant $6.25
Smoked turkey breast, ham, swiss cheese and bacon with lettuce and tomato.

• Chicken Salad Sandwich $6.25
All white chicken breast meat with red grapes and tarragon. Served on your choice
of croissant, roll or wrap.

• Tuna Salad Sandwich $6.25
Made with 100% albacore white tuna, cheddar cheese and dill. Served on your choice
of croissant, roll or wrap.

• Egg Salad Sandwich $6.25
Made fresh daily with chives and seasoned with curry.

• Turkey, Ham or Roast Beef $6.25
Fresh sliced turkey, ham or roast beef served with provolone cheese, lettuce and tomato.
Served on your choice of croissant, roll or wrap.

• Grilled Chicken Breast $6.75
Mesquite grilled chicken breast served with provolone, lettuce and tomato.
(Not available as half sandwich)

• Veggie Sandwich $6.25
Roasted red pepper hummus, provolone, shredded carrots, lettuce and tomato.

• Muffaletta $6.25 Served Hot!
Salami, ham and olive tapenade with melted provolone cheese served on Italian roll.

- All Sandwiches served on your choice of roll, croissant, or wrap with your choice of veggies or potato chips.

Cupcakes!

Everyone loves them and some days we cannot bake them fast enough!

They're portable.

They don't require a knife and fork.

It's fun to peel the paper away.

They provide nostalgia.

They're guilt-reduced because of the size.

They come in a variety of flavors and they're fairly cheap!

Some of our popular flavors are: Chocolate Peanut Butter, Black and White, Funfetti,
Chocolate Cheesecake, Red Velvet, Vanilla Bean, Cookies and Cream, and Spice!

Prices are $2.25 each

Please call ahead for special orders or to see what other flavors are available!

Let the talented staff at Short North Piece of Cake create the cake of your dreams! 
Bring us your ideas and let us make a cake that will have your guests talking and
wanting more. We can create anything from simple and understated to extravagant
and over the top.  

Please place your order at least 3 days in advance to ensure best selection.  Last minute
orders can usually be fulfilled, but selections and flavors may be limited.

Listed below are our most popular cake flavors and fillings as well as basic cake pricing. 
If you don’t see what you are looking for just ask and we will see if we can do it!

View our specialty cakes gallery

Traditional Cake Flavors

Deluxe Cake Flavors

Italian Cassada yellow cake with a layer of custard, fresh strawberries and whipped cream frosting

Opera Cream Torte light chocolate cake with a vanilla cream filling and chocolate ganache frosting

Chocolate Truffle dense chocolate cake with chocolate chips and chocolate ganache filling and frosting

Italian Cream dense butter cake with coconut and pecans with cream cheese filling and frosting

 

Traditional Fillings 

Deluxe Fillings

Traditional Frostings

Deluxe Frostings

Sizes, Servings, and Prices

• 6" Round-4 to 6 servings $19.00 Traditional/ $21.00 Deluxe

• 8" Round-8 to 10 servings $28.00 Traditional/$30.00 Deluxe

• 10" Round-12 to 15 servings $42.00 Traditional/$45.00 Deluxe

• 12" Round-25 to 30 servings $54.00 Traditional/$60.00 Deluxe

• 1/4 Sheet-12 to 24 servings $36.00 Traditional/$40.00 Deluxe

• 1/2 Sheet-30 to 48 servings $54.00 Traditional/$60.00 Deluxe

• Full Sheet-70 to 96 servings $100.00 Traditional/$112.00 Deluxe

• Cupcakes $2.25 each/$2.50 Filled

• Some designs may incur additional charges

Download Our Print-Friendly CATERING MENU

Breakfast Trays

Your choice of mini-muffins, coffee cake, cinnamon rolls & scones.

Juice and coffee service add $1.25 per person.

• 12 person, 36 pcs. / $28.00 

• 20 person, 60 pcs. / $45.00 

• 25 person, 75 pcs. / $56.00

Boxed Lunches

Your choice of sandwich, chips or veggies, and cookie.

Price: $7.25 - With soft drink: $8.00

(Does not include Panini)

Sandwich Trays

Your choice of sandwiches on croissants, wraps, or rolls. 

• 8 person / $52.00 

• 12 person / $74.00 

• 18 person / $108.00

• Additional Sandwiches $5.50 each

(Does not include Panini)

Pastry Trays

Your choice of mini-cheesecakes, mini-éclairs, creampuffs, bar cookies, brownies, and mini-tarts. 

• 12 person, 36 pcs. / $34.00 

• 20 person, 60 pcs. / $57.50

• 25 person, 75 pcs. / $68.50

Relish Trays

Relish trays with assorted fresh vegetables and ranch dip. 

• 12 person / $25.00 

• 25 person / $47.00

• 36 person / $69.00

Fruit Trays

Fruit kabobs with fresh berries and melon (seasonal).

• 12 person / $40.00 

• 25 person / $80.00

• 36 person / $114.00

Cookie Trays

Your choice of assorted European style cookies.

• 16 person, 48 pcs. / $32.00 

• 24 person, 72 pcs. / $47.00 

• 40 person, 120 pcs. / $76.00

*All trays can have more cookies added for an additional $7.00 per dozen

VISA & MasterCard accepted

• $15.00 delivery charge in downtown area w/ $40.00 min. order.

• Plates and utensils available – 25¢ per person. 

• 24 hour notice requested on all orders, substitutions, and changes.

Short North Piece of Cake is a neighborhood bakery and lunch destination located in the
heart of the Short North. Stop in and check out our wide variety of desserts, pastries,
cakes, cookies and muffins.

At Piece of Cake we specialize in birthday cakes, anniversary cakes, wedding cakes,
3-d cakes, and cakes for all occasions.

We also offer cupcakes, cheesecakes, pies and cookies. Our lunch menu offers
sandwiches, pannini, soup and salads, all made fresh to order!

 

Cakes in all kinds of shapes and sizes are our specialty!  Let us turn your imagination into a
custom creation. Short North Piece of Cake has what it takes to make your child’s special
occasion perfect!  Click on the photo above for a few samples of what we can do.

(Unfortunately, due to copyright laws some images and cartoon characters are not
possible for us to duplicate.)

Our wedding cakes are truly delicious pieces of art, custom designed to your wishes,
ranging from simple and elegant to elaborate and extraordinary. All of our cakes are made 
from scratch using the finest ingredients available. Baked, decorated and delivered fresh 
for your special day! 

Enjoy our  Wedding Cake Gallery  

With over 12 years of experience you can rely on us to create the wedding cake
of your dreams!

*Always FREE wedding cake delivery within the Columbus Ohio area for orders
 over $300.00!

*FREE personalized consultation

*FREE use of wedding cake stands and pedestals

Call us today to schedule your free personal consultation – 614.421.0399

Our Location
Short North Piece of Cake is located at the corner of High St. & Warren St. (facing Warren St.) at 772 North High St., Columbus, Ohio 43215

Contact Us 
Phone: (614) 421-0399
Fax: (614) 737-0401
Email: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it  
Hours: Monday thru Saturday 8am to 5pm

View Larger Map